Most New Managers Are Clueless

Photo by Finding Dan | Dan Grinwis on Unsplash

Finding the First Rung — A study on the challenges facing today’s frontline leader, surveyed 1,130 supervisors and first-level managers to understand how they’re overcoming the challenges of their jobs and what is holding them back from being successful.

The major findings of the study include:

• 42% of new managers don’t understand what it takes to succeed

• 89% have at least one blind spot

• Only 1 in 10 leaders were actually groomed for the job

• Half took the role an increase in compensation — only 23% actually wanted to lead others

• More than half of leaders learned through trial and error

Being Blind Sided

So why were leaders so surprised by the job? Since trial and error on the job (57%) was the number one most influential thing to achieving their leadership skills, it’s not surprising that these leaders were shocked once they were formally in the role.

And even if they’ve been in the role for a year or two, 30% of leaders still don’t understand what it takes to be successful — after six years, that number is still only 10% lower, with 1 in 5 leaders who don’t understand what it takes.

The result of this gap is leadership regret — 1 out of 3 leaders surveyed regretted being promoted due to lack of preparation and or not knowing how to succeed.

Some of that distress can be attributed to how people got the job — 11% of respondents said they became a leader because there was no one else for the job. These ‘accidental leaders’ regretted the promotion the most, were less likely to have wanted the promotion to begin with and more likely to question their ability to lead others.

Management by default isn’t an effective promotion strategy. Companies need to do due diligence to select leaders who have the desire, motivation — and skills — to be a leader or you’ve failed the individual and the organization.

Thrown into the Deep End — and Not Liking It

For the half of leaders who found themselves learning from trial and error (when compared to those who learned through manager support), they felt less supported, that they were getting fewer good learning experiences and were overall less satisfied with their development.

Managers learning through trial and error were 52% more likely to describe their first year on the job as stressful and twice as likely to describe it as overwhelming.

While learning tension is good, the stress from having to navigate a complex role with little support takes a toll on morale and creates negative feeling from leaders.

In fact when you compare leaders who learned through manager support to those who learned from trial and error, the number of leaders who said they were less interested in being a leader more than doubled (9% manager support to 20% trial and error).

Lack of management support when transitioning to the role also took a toll on self-esteem as those learning from trial and error were a great deal more likely to rate themselves as poor or fair (18% compared to 7% with manager support) and were twice as likely to say they were unprepared to take on the job (20% compared to 9% of those with manager support).

What can we learn from this? The manager’s role — and ultimately the company’s responsibility — in helping a new leader impacts everything from their perception of leadership to their perception of themselves.

All the Wrong Reasons

When asked about the top two reasons for taking the promotion, half of frontline leaders surveyed took the role because it would lead to great compensation — the number one reason for becoming a leader. What lagged behind? Broadening skills (39%), to advance their career (33%), making a greater contribution to the company (33%), and power and influence (21%). Surprisingly, wanting to lead others was almost at the bottom of the list of leader’s with only 23%.

Leading others is one of the biggest changes for those transitioning from an individual contributor to manager, but it’s a central part of the job, so the low motivation to lead should be concerning to organizations.”

What’s the downside to the financial motivation? They were more likely to become disillusioned by the job — they are 57% more likely to regret the promotion than those who wanted to make a greater contribution.

Seeing (blind) Spots

Can leaders see themselves clearly and identify their skill gaps? Even with the low confidence and regret reported, 87% of leaders rated themselves as good or excellent.

In separate data from 200 managers going through a frontline leader assessment, their self-ratings of their leadership skills were compared to their actual performance during the assessment. Nearly all of the managers (89%) rated themselves above their actual skill level on at least one leadership skill — and half rated themselves higher on at least three.

P.S > I’m going to keep posting this on Medium — in aeternum — for free. If you want to pay* for these posts to continue, you can do so here, here or here.

Top writer in Venture Capital

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

How Design Thinking makes you a better leader

manager motivates employees

Lessons in Goals, Leadership and Death from Alexander the Great

The Paradox of Responsibility

What the president of Ukraine is teaching us about purpose

Team Role — Juggler

8 Best Practices for Business

When is focusing on your strengths not enough?

tree on porch.jpg

Best Advice from 13 Impactful Leaders

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Zachary Lukasiewicz

Zachary Lukasiewicz

Top writer in Venture Capital

More from Medium

Five Impactful Tips on Building a Personal Brand From a (Former) Management Consultant

3 Things You Must Know About The Great Dispersion Economy

19 Simple Business Writing Tips To Dramatically Improve Every Teams Communication

Don’t Be a Rooster — Writing and Using Sales Scripts is the Key to Becoming a Top Producing Sales…